Skip to main content
Board Review Methodology

How your community
actually makes decisions

A Board Review reads the public meeting record and shows three things: how the officials who hold decision-making authority have voted on business matters, how the offices around them performed, and who answers for each of them. Every finding cites the record it rests on, so any conclusion can be checked against the minutes it came from.

6 Scored dimensions
1–5 Rating scale
Votes Primary evidence
0 Private citizens named

Where it comes from

Everything in a Board Review is built from the public record — the minutes and agendas of your own meetings, the same documents any resident could request. Nothing is inferred from private sources, and every finding cites the specific record it rests on, so any conclusion can be checked against the document it came from.

How it works

1. We map the organization

Every body and committee, who serves on each, and how they got there — elected, appointed, hired or contracted.

2. You confirm who’s who

You check the list and correct it before any analysis runs. Titles mean different things in different communities, so the person who knows decides. You can hand it to a colleague to check.

3. We read the record

Votes, motions and statements are scored across six business-climate dimensions, the same framework as your BFI survey. Votes carry the most weight, because a vote is the action with consequences.

4. The people in it review it

Before delivery, those named see the findings that concern them and the records cited, and have at least five business days to respond. You decide each point they raise.

You get a scorecard for each body and each named official, an accountability map showing who appoints, employs or oversees each office, key findings, and a roster of who served during the period. Reviewed annually, it becomes a record of whether anything changed.

Who is named

One test, and it is a fact rather than a judgement: does this person hold a public office? Elected to a governing body, or appointed to a planning commission, zoning board of appeals, or a development authority. We do not weigh how much authority a particular seat carries — a seat on a body that votes carries it.

Named and scored

  • Township board, city or village council
  • Planning commission
  • Zoning board of appeals
  • Downtown and economic development boards

Reported by office, not by name

  • Permit and counter staff
  • Inspectors applying an adopted code
  • Clerks and administrative staff
  • Private citizens and applicants

Their work is still reported, in full detail — as a finding about the office and the body accountable for it.

Elected and appointed are treated the same way. An appointed commissioner deciding a site plan exercises the same public authority as an elected trustee. Employees are a separate question: an employee is evaluated only where the position is itself a public office — a manager or administrator who directs the government — and where that is unclear, they are not.

Delegation does not move responsibility

Every adverse finding names the body that answers for it, and how — by appointment, by employment, or by statutory oversight. A governing body appoints most planning commissions and zoning boards and hires the administrative offices, so a finding about one of those is also a finding about the body that seated or employs it. Responsibility cannot be pushed down into the organization.

Each review includes an accountability map for your community, built from your own records and confirmed with you, so a reader can see where responsibility sits rather than having to infer it.

A response is a voice, not a veto

Everyone named gets to respond before the review is delivered. What that response can do depends on what it raises, not on who raises it:

Nobody named in a review holds a right of approval over it.

Safeguards

Why this exists

Township boards already know how businesses rate them — the Business Friendly Index survey tells them that. What's harder to see is which individual decisions and votes are driving that score. The Board Review closes that gap: it turns a stack of meeting minutes any resident could read into a clear, fair, board-level accountability record, and gives a community's leadership a concrete, individualized starting point for outreach and engagement.

Available Now

Board Review is generated with this exact methodology for any community with a completed Business Friendly Index Survey Report. Choose a Governing Body Review (the body scored as a whole on its collective votes and decisions — no individual member named or scored), Individual Member Reviews (a report card per member), or both — $399, $299, or $699 for both, one-time. Planning Commission Review is an add-on with the same choices and prices. The Complete plan includes the Governing Body Review of the board and of the Planning Commission; Individual Member Reviews are extra on every plan.

See a Sample Report Start with a Survey →